ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2025-02-20 01:48 pm

waging a good war

Thomas E. Ricks, Waging a Good War: How the Civil Rights Movement Won its Battles, 1954-1968.

Ricks is a U.S. military historian. If you're used to thinking about nonviolence as a set of lofty ideals, this project raises immediate questions: why would a military historian be interested? And why would someone who is morally committed to nonviolence--someone like me--care what he thinks?

But there's an intensely practical case for nonviolence as well. I learned this partly from reading Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan's work on nonviolent regime change, and partly by turning the counterinsurgency writing of David Kilcullen upside-down.

Here's the thing. Most people, regular people living under whatever government, just want to live their lives. To do that, they need to feel safe--not perfectly safe, but convinced that lightning or roving bands of leopards or the other generalized dangers of existence are unlikely to strike them personally. The task of a counterinsurgency operation is to convince people that their government can keep them safe. A group that wants to change government, for instance by overthrowing the incredibly repressive system of Jim Crow, needs to convince regular people that their government does not protect them.

One way to do this is to make the government's violence visible.

When you think of the civil rights movement this way, as a deliberate and ultimately successful campaign to confront a violent enemy, it's easier to see why a military historian would be interested.

Specifically, Waging a Good War is about the campaigns waged by the SCLC (Southern Christian Leadership Conference, Martin Luther King Jr.'s group) and the SNCC (Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee, the group that organized the Freedom Summer). It describes the Movement's strategy (how people chose, or failed to choose, their overarching goals) and tactics (how they pursued them), with regular comparisons to U.S. military campaigns. Most of the comparisons reference World War II; it's clear that Ricks prefers writing about people whom he thinks are the good guys, though he doesn't try to beatify any of the leaders whose decisions he examines.

If you're looking for an overview of the civil rights movement with an emphasis on techniques that other protest groups might try to emulate, this is a very solid place to start. I found, as I hoped, lots of practical information about planning and training. I learned about many civil rights leaders whose names I had not known, and learned more about people of whom I had only heard in passing. In particular, this book is full of praise for the leadership and insight of Diane Nash. As a mathematician, I was aware of the Algebra Project founded by Bob Moses (a very different person from the city planner by the same name!), but had no idea about his foundational role in Freedom Summer. That portion of my ignorance has now been rectified.

One theme that I did not anticipate is PTSD, or, as Ricks often terms it, combat stress. He devotes a substantial portion of the book to the question of what happens after a major operation, how survivors recover or fail to recover. I've seen echoes of the struggles Ricks describes among friends who were heavily involved in the Black Lives Matter protests. The questions he raises about how an organization might try to plan for the aftermath of a huge effort are important. Even in activist circles, I've generally heard this discussed in terms of individual burnout, rather than as a problem of collective support.

Waging a Good War is clear about its own scope. Some elements of the civil rights movement fall outside that scope; in particular, this is not the right place to find a detailed account of the NAACP's legal strategy. A more serious and less intentional limitation is that this book does not contemplate the U.S. as a colonialist power. Occasionally, this flavor of patriotism impedes Ricks' efforts to find an appropriate military simile. Here he is talking about J. Edgar Hoover's FBI, for example:

There are few analogies for this situation in conventional modern Western military history. Rather, Hoover operated like a medieval warlord, both an ally of the sovereign and a danger to him...


I am not a military expert, but I don't think it's difficult to find twentieth- and twenty-first century examples of the U.S. cooperating with people it termed warlords!

But this isn't the kind of book you read to stoke your cynicism; it's the kind of book you read to gear up for a long march. If you think a book like Waging a Good War could be useful to you, it almost certainly will.
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-09-26 08:31 pm

dragons and nightingales

Quick thoughts on a couple of books I've been meaning to review.

Moniquill Blackgoose, To Shape a Dragon's Breath.

This is a delightful alternate history involving resistance to colonialism, chemistry, and dragons. It's my favorite discovery from 2020 Hugo voting. The nuances of power and the self-centeredness associated to power are very well observed. In particular, though he's only a minor character--the story belongs to a young woman named Anequs from the island of Masquapaug and her dragon--I was fascinated by the jarl. One of the prices of doing a lot of historical re-creation is spending a lot of time around men who are pretending to be Viking kings, and I very much appreciated the precision with which Blackgoose renders a man who is genuinely (by his own standards) a wise and effective ruler, and yet is incapable of creating justice.

Ben Aaronovitch, The Masquerades of Spring.

A music-loving Englishman in early 1920s New York is visited by his old schoolfellow Thomas Nightingale. This is P.G. Wodehouse pastiche. The last time I read a novel actually written by P.G. Wodehouse that was set in New York, I reached the horrifyingly racist interlude in the middle of it while stuck on an airplane. That makes it tricky for me to relax into a story that's mostly about a nice feckless Bertie Wooster clone and his much cleverer boyfriend from Harlem rambling around the city enjoying jazz. On the opposite tack, there is a sad lack of aunts; I feel all Wodehousian prose is improved by a suitably forceful aunt. However, it's clear that Aaronovitch is enjoying himself greatly, and is perhaps particularly enjoying (after many volumes of fantasy police procedural) writing a book where the cops are the bad guys. There's also canonically asexual Nightingale, if you're interested in canonically asexual Nightingale.

(This novella comes out from Subterranean Press on September 30, at least in the US. I read it as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-07-20 11:04 am

the city in glass

Nghi Vo, The City in Glass.

The demon Vitrine loved the city of Azril until it was destroyed by angels. Her fury wounded one of the destroyers; no longer pure enough for his kindred, he is cursed to stay on Earth, wandering the ruins that were once Azril in pain and confusion.

I have a theory that some novellas are constructed like short stories and some are constructed like novels. The City in Glass is a novel that feels like a short story. The narrative arc is simple--the plot is essentially a love triangle, where Vitrine loves her city and the angel loves Vitrine--and the ending strikes with the force of a well-built short story. The complexities are in the streets and people of Azril itself: the tales that the angels cut off and the new tales that accumulate as different people arrive and begin to rebuild.

The City in Glass is in the same continuity as Vo's Singing Hills novellas. There's a passing reference to mastodons, and another to a cleric with a talking shrike. The angels and demons clearly draw on Christian mythology, but Christian mythology isn't privileged here above other mythologies: you won't find the attention to the hierarchies of Heaven and Hell that prevails in other stories about angels falling in love. Vitrine comes from a far-flung family of demons, each with its own talents and obsessions; they seem to be powers arising (super)naturally from the earth itself, rather than exiled angels. The angels, meanwhile, are terrifyingly destructive and terrifyingly good. We never learn why Azril was destroyed, or whether the angels serve a God. The focus is instead on grief, rebuilding, and the inevitability of change. Even immortality is not altogether constant.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC. In the US, it comes out October 1.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-05-12 08:58 am

the brides of high hill

Nghi Vo, The Brides of High Hill.

The cleric Chih is accompanying a beautiful merchant's daughter to the rich compound on the top of a hill where her betrothed awaits. This man has had other wives, but they have all left or disappeared; if it weren't for the strange pronouncements of his possibly-mad eldest son, one could assume they had never existed. Chih is uneasy about everything, especially the fate of her charming new friend.

Vo's Singing Hills novellas always play with genre. Brides of High Hill is obviously invoking the gothic novel, nurse with too much laudanum and all. But there's another genre of creepy stories at play. One hint that something weird is going on is that Chih, who usually collects everyone's stories, can't get any of the servants to talk to them--they don't even seem to know any of the hangers-on in the merchants' retinue. It's easy to overlook these worries, when the mundane implications of the looming marriage are so terrifying; it would be fascinating to re-read this novella, assuming it never was a gothic novel.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC; in the US, it's out now.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-04-06 02:32 pm

Lady Eve's Last Con

Lady Eve's Last Con, Rebecca Fraimow.

Ruthi Johnson (currently going by Evelyn Ojukwu) is running a con on the awkward heir of a major intergalactic insurance concern to get back at him for jilting her baby sister. But it's hard to focus on breaking Esteban's heart when his wildly dashing half-sister is standing right next to him.

This--like the ostensible Miss Ojukwu's game--is the kind of project that takes a massive amount of craftsmanship to pull off while seeming light-hearted and casual the entire time. There's an immense satisfaction in watching the various gears line up. If you're thinking of Ruthi's universe as a hand-crafted mechanism, it's one with a surprising heft: early twentieth-century musical comedy IN SPACE needs no extra justification, but I appreciated the depth in Fraimow's imagined cultures. Even the seemingly frothiest fashions are based on assumptions about where money comes from and how it is used, and there are layers and layers beneath questions such as why debutantes wear bubble-dresses (the better to dance in half-gravity!) or when it's gauche to take a radiation pill before eating, to say nothing of the best methods for interstellar transport of kosher duck.

(I read this book as a NetGalley ARC; in the US, it comes out on June 4.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-03-03 02:57 pm

Lake of Souls

Lake of Souls is a collection of Ann Leckie's short fiction, divided into three sections: stories about the Radch, stories in the same universe as Raven Tower, and independent universes. The title story "Lake of Souls" (a novelette) is new; other stories have appeared in various places (as always with short fiction, some are easier to track down than others).

Leckie often experiments with point of view and different writing styles, and I enjoyed comparing the ways that individual stories emphasize one strand or another of her multitudinous interests. There's an undercurrent of horror in the Ancillary books, and some of the shorts (particularly "Footprints") bring it to the surface. "Lake of Souls" mixes gooey alien creepiness with a space-opera take on rapacious corporations that feels a lot like Murderbot or Leckie's recent short for Amazon, "The Long Game"; the aliens, as one might expect, are outstanding. "Hesperia and Glory" riffs on planetary romance; it has a nineteenth-century-style frame story with the intriguing refrain, "There is not now, nor has there ever been, a well in my cellar." I was glad to discover the layers of scheming, gamesmanship, and Breq's characteristic decisiveness in "She Commands Me and I Obey," an Ancillary-universe story I knew only by reputation. But my favorites are the Raven Tower stories: the rule that gods dare not speak a truth they cannot guarantee makes for fascinating puzzles, and I always enjoy the opportunity to explore other corners of this world.

(I read this collection as a Netgalley ARC; in the US, it comes out on April 2.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2024-02-23 10:07 pm

dead cat tail assassins

The heroine of P. Djèlí Clark's The Dead Cat Tail Assassins is the undead assassin Eveen, nicknamed "The Eviscerator." Perhaps I should have recognized this was inevitable, but I was startled to find that the end of the book
involves Eveen...involves Eveen and a newfound comrade torturing the antagonist to death.

The antagonist is a villain of the grandest sort, so if you're someone who finds the notion of retribution emotionally satisfying, maybe this will work for you. I'm not. I'm willing to read about torture, and even willing to read about protagonists who engage in torture, but an authorial stance that frames it as just is a hard no for me, even in stylized adventure stories. I would have set the book down unfinished if I hadn't already been on the last page.


Until that bloodthirsty denouement, Dead Cat Tail Assassins is a fun, snappy, fantasy adventure with a mix of wizardly and divine double-crossing. In some ways, the reading experience feels the way I imagine it must have felt to discover Steven Brust's Jhereg in the '80s: the braided timelines, the banter, the novelty of a fantasy setting that has no investment in mythologizing England. I missed some of the richness of the contrast between history and fantasy in Clark's Cairo stories, but I loved the late-book faceoff between divine powers and the booklong tug-of-war between Eveen and her intended target, who looks oddly like a younger version of herself.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-08-20 01:41 pm

obstacles and exile

Aliette de Bodard, A Fire Born of Exile, and Malka Older, The Imposition of Unnecessary Obstacles.

These are both smart, good-hearted queer romances that reference nineteenth-century novels and are written on the principle of incorporating as many of the writer's escapist impulses as possible. I suspect this means that how well they work for you will depend on how closely the writer's psyche mirrors yours.

I loved Older's previous novella in this sequence, Mimicking of Known Successes, and Unnecessary Obstacles was just as good. The general setup is lesbian Sherlock Holmes on Jupiter, with an academic devoted to studying lost Earth ecologies in the role of Watson. Pursuing intellectual questions by reading old books by a cozy fire while somebody else bakes the scones is absolutely wish-fulfilment. But Older's well aware of the layers of exploitation built into university projects, real or imaginary, and both the mystery plot and the romantic uncertainties depend on the protagonist Pleiti's growing awareness of these inequities.

My feelings about Fire Born of Exile are more mixed. The reference for this one is the Count of Monte Cristo. I've read another Count of Monte Cristo in space novel (Gwyneth Jones' Spirit: or, The Princess of Bois Dormant), but I've only read the very beginning of the original novel. I think it might have helped to know going in that the main arc is "protagonist wonders whether an elaborately planned revenge has gone too far" rather than heist-like competence fireworks around the revenge itself. I ended up most invested in the third viewpoint character, the teenager Minh who is trying to break free from her mother the cruel judge, rather than either of the romantic leads.

This is a book with lots of kids, from teenagers to toddlers. Some are human and some are spaceships (as one might expect from a de Bodard novel), but all are charming and generally good-hearted. Aliette de Bodard has written about the erasure of mothers in fiction, and it's clear that the presence of children in her work is a matter of both love and politics. If representation of parents and parental figures is important to you, you'll find it here in spades.

The danger of this particular mission is that being good with kids can become shorthand for being a good person. Fire Born of Exile definitely slips over this line from time to time. I don't find it as claustrophobic as, say, the recent work of Lois Bujold, which often reads like a memo requesting more grandchildren, because de Bodard is interested in relationships of siblings, aunts, teachers, and informal mentors as well as literal mothers. But it doesn't bring me the sense of expanded possibility it might hold for another reader.

(I read both of these books as Netgalley ARCs.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-08-06 11:04 am

mammoths at the gates

Nghi Vo, Mammoths at the Gates.

Chih is a cleric who travels the world collecting stories with a startlingly intelligent bird for a companion. At the beginning of this novella, Chih returns home to the Singing Hills Abbey--but the abbey is strangely empty, and there are, as you might have guessed, war-mammoths at the gates.

All of Vo's books about Chih are built around the ways the same story can be told. They're always fascinating on an intellectual level, but some stories will inevitably lie closer to the heart than others. This one lies close to mine.

Returning to a place you used to call home and finding both you and it has changed is a theme that has obvious autobiographical resonance for me. But I'm also interested in the facets of this specific story, which involves memories of a person who was a beloved leader to the clerics and an honored grandfather to a pair of warriors, and the way Vo refuses to let the messages resolve into anything as simple as "This person was good" or "This person was bad" (OK, maybe there's some autobiographically resonant grief there, too). I also enjoyed learning more about those long-remembering birds, the neixin, who have been a matter-of-fact background element in many of the Chih stories, but now come to the fore.

Though many of the novellas in this series could be read in whatever order you joyfully stumbled upon them, this one does assume some existing curiosity about Chih and their world, so it might not be the right place to start. It's definitely one to look forward to, though!

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC. In the US, it comes out in September.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-08-02 08:44 pm

labyrinth's heart

M.A. Carrick, Labyrinth's Heart.

This is the third and final book in the Rook & Rose trilogy, which began with The Mask of Mirrors. Ren is confronted with an unexpected rival for society's attention: the person she has been pretending is her mother. She loves the family she has pretended is hers, in whose register her name is now inscribed--but what will those affections mean as her lies begin to unravel? Does that even matter, when the city she calls home strains under the weight of an ancient curse?

This series is lively, adventurous, and intricately plotted. In this installment, Ren learns more about her birth family, including the Vraszenian culture whose rituals she only half-remembers, if she ever learned them at all. The quest to lift the curse reveals ancient secrets, too, including the true nature of the murderous zlyzen. To protect her city and claim her true love, Ren will have to integrate all the fractured aspects of her self.

There are a ton of balls in the air here, and I can't guarantee that every one will land in the spot a particular reader hopes for. I was somewhat frustrated with a plot strand involving Ren's adopted cousin Tanaquis, a scholar obsessed with understanding the connections between the academic magic of inscription and the Tarot-like Vraszenian pattern decks. The plot depends on Ren taking a dismissive attitude towards Tanaquis's admittedly significant weirdness, and though Ren eventually regrets her actions, the whole thing rings a bit oddly if you're naturally inclined to be most sympathetic to Tanaquis (I studied math and Latin, I think we all know where my interests lie). I would have liked to know more about the fate of Ren's other cousin Giuna's exciting flirtation, too. We do learn the identity of Ren's father--it's even weirder than I suspected, and I've read my share of eighteenth-century novels--as well as all sorts of things about the history of the shadowy Rook.

If you're already reading this series, Labyrinth's Heart will give you lots to think about. If you haven't found it yet, it's well worth finding Mask of Mirrors and embarking on the journey.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-02-05 04:37 pm

iron children

Rebecca Fraimow, The Iron Children.

In this forthcoming novella, a young woman named Asher finds herself in command of a group of Dedicates--soldiers given iron bodies to fight a desperate, defensive war--on the edge of a mountain in winter. But one of her Dedicates is a spy.

I have a soft spot for the military-fiction trope of the sergeant who knows way more about what's going on than their commanding officer, and the sergeant in Iron Children is pretty great. But this isn't, fundamentally, a story about who's going to win the war. It's about what it means to be an ordinary person living through one piece of it.

I know Fraimow's writing from her historical fiction about being queer and Jewish. Though Iron Children's Dedicates are commanded by a military order of nuns, this feels like a story with a Jewish ethos: the characters belong to (multiple, distinct) religious minorities, and each individual has to figure out what being ethical means on their own, and then live up to it. There are gripping snow-survival moments and knotty questions about agency. Sometimes these are literalized questions about who controls a Dedicate's iron body, presented with the kind of intensity and specificity that fantasy does best.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC. Fun fact: it's a novella that's coming out from Solaris! It's nice to see more imprints publishing fiction at this length.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-01-14 08:11 pm
Entry tags:

January journal: choosing books

[personal profile] flowersforgraves asked, "What do you look for or search by if you're looking for new things to read (i.e. are you more likely to pick up something if it's by an author you've previously read in a different genre, vs if it's a similar genre but an unfamiliar author, etc.)?"

This is a great question! I definitely read by author, and sometimes I read everything by a particular author. This can be systematic, if I really like someone's work, but sometimes I casually pick up books by the same author until it turns out I've read all of them. Sofia Samatar is a "read everything, quickly" writer for me, for instance; I initially read her novels, then her collected short stories and prose poetry, and I'm really looking forward to her new memoir.

I don't keep an official to-read list--I'd rather read whatever seems most fun to me at any given moment--but if I come across a rec or review of something that sounds intriguing, I'll add it to either a wishlist or my library ebook holds. I scroll through my wishlist when I want to read a new book but I'm not sure what book I want to read. (The wishlist I use for this purpose lives on Amazon, but all else being equal I'd rather give other people money, so once I pick a book, I often buy it from somewhere else or request it from a library.)

I do pay attention to which writers blurb which books, especially when I'm browsing in a library or bookstore. The extreme case here is Fonda Lee's Jade City: the library hardback was covered in blurbs. I inferred that it was Asian-inspired secondary-world fantasy that people who care about worldbuilding liked a lot and checked it out on that basis. When I started reading, I was startled to discover it was based on twentieth-century rather than medieval history.

Another thing I do when browsing in person is read pages out of the middle of a book to see what I make of the prose and general attitude. When I was younger I'd also read the last page of a book to check whether it was unbelievably depressing, but these days I have both more interest in tragedies and more faith in my ability to guess a book's emotional tenor from other clues. The last book I read because I'd enjoyed pages chosen from the middle of a book is Saad Z. Hossain's Djinn City, which was fascinating, sometimes hilarious, and sometimes bleak. It does end on a massive cliffhanger, but (in full disclosure) the book I flipped through physically was a sequel, so I couldn't exactly have checked.
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2023-01-09 08:02 pm

Rose/House

Arkady Martine's Rose/ House takes preoccupations that readers of her novel A Memory Called Empire will be familiar with--a living place, the impression that a dead man leaves behind him, the seductions of intellectual fascination, the way an idea you love can cut you open--and refracts them through a different genre. Memory Called Empire and its sequel A Desolation Called Peace were adventure stories: there's a protagonist setting forth to learn more about the world, a beautiful woman, nobility engaged in elaborate plots, startling self-sacrifice, and a stack of similar motifs you might have met anywhere between Cherryh's Foreigner series and The Three Musketeers. Meanwhile, Rose/ House is a ghost story--a science fiction ghost story, with climate change and artificial intelligence and an architectural marvel in the Mojave desert all held up to the prism.

Rose/ House isn't coy about its genre. We're told early on that, "Yeah, Maritza grew up here, she knows like anyone else that Rose House is a haunt, and was glad when it was shut up inside with itself for good." The word "haunt" persists and multiplies, occasionally as the adjective commonly applied to houses, more often as that stark noun. But there are references to other genres too--casual references to carjackings for water rations, a detective who stubbornly investigates an inexplicable corpse--and I was inclined at first to read the book as a mystery. That's not the core. The core is the house itself: intelligent, inhuman, and beautifully, terrifyingly interested.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-10-29 05:31 pm

gaspunk on a gas giant

The Mimicking of Known Successes, Malka Older.

I requested this book because it was by Malka Older and then slammed the download button without re-reading the marketing copy, which means I went in cold, with no conscious knowledge of the concept, length, or premise. It's novella-length; if you want to recreate my experience of reading the entire book in one joyful Friday evening of discovery, hit the pre-order button now.

Mimicking of Known Successes is the kind of book you get when a really smart person makes a list of their favorite tropes and then writes them all simultaneously. (In that sense, Aliette de Bodard's novellas are a good comparison.) To give you an example, at one point two characters visit their favorite restaurant:

Slow Burn was, most exceptionally, in the center of a small but dense wood. The owner had purchased soil, and saplings, and cultivated the fastest-growing firewood species she could find, all within her small allotted plot on Valdegeld platform. Tiny paths led through the trees to a slender building, and within the visitor found a long hearth...


There are layers on layers here: a joke about the book's central relationship, a cozy fire, an example of the crafted ecological management/historical recreation that forms the viewpoint character's career, and a reference to the platforms along rails above a gas giant that form both story setting and mystery structure.

The one major element of the premise you can't extract from this piece of gleeful scene-setting is that in addition to being a gaslights-on-a-gas-giant ecological adventure, Known Successes is a lesbian riff on Sherlock Holmes. Or maybe it's as fair to say, a queer riff. The Holmes character is clearly a woman, but for a while I thought the Watsonesque narrator's gender was deliberately ambiguous in the style of the Hilary Tamar mysteries. That was a misapprehension on my part, but the rumpled academia readings are certainly comparable to the Hilary Tamar books. You'll also find hot scones and levels of hurt/comfort you could scoop up with a spoon--and background musings on ecological disequilibrium.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-10-15 01:01 pm

Furious Heaven

As a teenager, I vowed never to read another book that said "epic" on the cover. I was tired of stories that stacked cliffhanger on cliffhanger, accumulating points of view without resolution. I read Kate Elliott's Furious Heaven, the sequel to Unconquerable Sun, without knowing the final cover design, so I don't know whether reading it violated my vow. But I can report that Furious Heaven is a rare thing: a sprawling, multistranded story about galactic conquest that reaches a satisfying resolution in two volumes. There could be a sequel--and indeed, it seems that Elliott is planning one--but there doesn't have to be. That's a difficult balance to strike!

Furious Heaven begins with a hefty dose of dynastic plotting. Princess Sun, the story's Alexander the Great equivalent, is her mother's most likely heir, but her succession is not inevitable, and plenty of people both within and outside the Republic of Chaonia would love to introduce some chaos. Sun's new Companion, the brash Persephone, is impatient with politics, but she's more embedded in systems of privilege than she recognizes. Meanwhile, Lieutenant Apama at Sabao, who wanted to be an ordinary fighter pilot, is stuck dancing attendance on her father, one of the cabal of people with two literal faces that rules her empire. Apama's father wields power in a way that's most terrifying for its boringness--he doesn't need to posture villainously when he can simply command.

There's a point in Furious Heaven where Sun concludes that sustained aggression is safer than standing still. I tore through the book's second half in a rush, caught up in Sun's momentum. Elliott does a phenomenal job of conveying both the strategic logic and its contingency on tiny circumstance. Sun is successful despite and because of the risks she takes.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-08-14 09:45 pm

into the Riverlands

Into the Riverlands is the third in Nghi Vo's series of novellas about Chih, a cleric who wanders the world with their highly intelligent not-quite-bird companion, collecting stories and histories for their monastery. Each of the novellas experiments with genre, contrasting the shape of the way a story is told with the ways people frame their own experiences. The Riverlands genre is wuxia: the Riverlands are beset by bandits, but they also provide a place where weird, stubborn people with startling martial talents can find a way to flourish.

Into the Riverlands pairs well with Zen Cho's Order of the Pure Moon Reflected in Water, another novella influenced by both wuxia and queer American fantasy. Both stories feature members of religious orders who aren't saintly in the ways one might expect. Chih is polite, but not always socially deft, despite their skill at extracting stories. They have no trace of martial skill, and are unnerved by death the way ordinary people often are and fantasy protagonists often aren't. But they take their new and strange traveling companions in stride, and their companions return the favor, protecting them with casual grace.

(I read this book as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-07-17 06:21 pm
Entry tags:

Oleander Sword

Tasha Suri's novel The Oleander Sword is the middle book in a planned trilogy that began with The Jasmine Throne. It's the kind of book that comes with maps and lists of characters from different countries, and it opens with a war, as Malini, who has just crowned herself Empress, seeks to defeat her fanatical, princely brother. But Oleander Sword doesn't sprawl across new viewpoint characters and their disconnected subplots, the way one might expect from a book in this sort of package. It's fundamentally a very focused story. Half is how Malini will balance her drive to consolidate power with her love for Priya, once a servant girl. The other half is how Priya, newly filled with magical force from the treelike yaksa she worshipped as a child, will square the demands of her own power with her love for Malini. There are sudden betrayals and the fulfillments of mysterious prophecies--the book's title, in particular, cuts in an unexpected way--but if you've read Jasmine Throne, the confrontation that Oleander Sword sets up for the final volume will not astonish you. The satisfaction is not in authorial sleight of hand, but rather in game pieces clicking into place.

Suri's fantasy novels are inspired by medieval India, rather than vague impressions of England or France, and I particularly enjoy the way that this upends fantasy conventions. Inheritance isn't driven by birth order, for instance, and the trope of the ambitious priest carries different weight.
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-04-10 03:45 pm

Goliath

I have a reviewerly confession to make: I never finished Parable of the Sower. I read every other Octavia Butler book I could get my hands on as a teenager--my favorite was the Imago series, which tugged on my feelings about desire, embodiment, and trauma in ways I was not ready to articulate--but I didn't want to read then about the ways in which teenage girls are powerless, and I have not returned as an adult. That means I can't tell you whether Tochi Onyebuchi's novel Goliath is like Parable of the Sower in any deep and fundamental sense. But it is absolutely like the way people talk about Parable of the Sower.

If you want to read a gorgeous, literary, terrifying near-future novel about race in America--if you want to metabolize a brilliant person's take on where things are going that you may look back on, thirty years from now, to say, "Fuck they were right"--you should read Goliath.

I read Tochi Onyebuchi because I am personally and abidingly angry at the American quote-on-quote justice system in ways that middle-class white people mostly don't talk about. (Grand sweep of ideas? Yes. Background-radiation family trauma? Not so much.) This puts me in an odd position as a reviewer, because on one hand there are huge swathes of this book that are familiar in the sense of familial, and on the other hand I'm white and this book isn't for me, in ways it makes painstakingly clear.

This book is also not for Jonathan. That might be less obvious, because Jonathan is a prominent viewpoint character, especially in the early sections. Jonathan grew up on a space station, safely away from polluted, climate-crashing Earth, but he has working-class New Haven roots, and he yearns to go back. He also yearns for his boyfriend David.

Basic English-lit-class training tells you that if you're reading a book called Goliath about characters named David and Jonathan, tragedy is coming. This is perfectly true. Goliath is a tragedy in the technical sense--someday, a high school student is going to write an essay on hubris and catharsis in this novel, and when they do, I hope they get an A. But neither David nor Jonathan is the tragic hero.

At the center of Goliath are the stackers. Most of New Haven--the parts not under domes--will kill you if you're not wearing a breath mask. But the houses are still beautiful. A drone can reduce a house to its components in seconds. Then a crew of humans collects the lovely, weathered brick. It's tough, physical, satisfying work, if you don't think too hard about the symbolism.

In the space of a year, the team--Bishop, Linc, Mercedes, Bugs, Timeica, Sydney, and their colleagues--becomes a sort of family. Much of Goliath is a sort of literary collage, telling you who the stackers are, where they came from, what kinds of grief they carry, what kinds of grief are impossible to carry--and what they find that is beautiful, and what happens in the spring.

(I read this book as a NetGalley ARC, but it's now available to everyone!)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2022-02-10 10:11 pm
Entry tags:

last exit

Max Gladstone's forthcoming novel Last Exit is aimed straight at me.

Why me, specifically? When I turned forty last year, I had the following conversation with [personal profile] redshiftnova:


Me: I hadn't planned on having a midlife crisis, but instead I got a worldwide pandemic.
Red: YOU OVERACHIEVER!!!


This was hilarious--and it's the precise set of baggage that the characters of Last Exit carry. The age; the scholarship to an elite East Coast college (Last Exit is about Yale, and I went to a small liberal-arts college whose students prided themselves on being smarter and working harder than the Ivy League trust fund kids, but that just means the sweatshirts came in garnet instead of navy); the math degree driven by the lure of impossible things; the exhortations to save the world; the knowledge that the world is falling apart.

The world is ending; but the world has always been ending. The question is whose world, and whose world you think matters. Last Exit is an American novel, a big sprawling ensemble-cast American road trip novel, and the question of who exactly has been fucked how badly by the continuation of America is never far from the surface.

Flip things around, try the active voice: will a terrified person fuck things over, to keep America the same? Last Exit asks the question that way, too.

This is what the novel is about, in a grand thematic sense. But what happens? The story begins in New York City, as Zelda, a grown-up gay kid from small-town South Carolina, is preparing to apologize for losing her lover Sal. Instead of Sal's mother, she meets Sal's teenage cousin June. June is a veteran of the BLM protests; she has watched cops on horses try to kill her friends. She doesn't want Zelda's apology for failure. She wants to try again.

New York City has a solid weight; it knows what it is. But Zelda has a knack for going other places, and in less populated spots, or when people are looking away, she can walk (or ride or drive) to other possible worlds. Turn The City We Became inside out, and send it on the road to Amber.

Send it back to Montana, where Zelda fucked things up the first time.

Bring the team back together: Sarah (a doctor, married, a mom, an Army brat, Sarah whose sister has gone home to the reservation), Ramón (who tried to go into finance but found his soul again fixing cars), Ish (whose Silicon Valley surveillance company watches for the serpent eating the heart of the world), Zelda, and June (who looks like Sal, and isn't). Retrace the steps of the last adventure, to the Green Glass City, and the tower where they met the princess.

Meanwhile, something is following our friends: the reason that the world is ending, growing tangible. Last Exit has a lot of horror in its DNA. Things are twisted. Bodies are twisted into non-Euclidean geometries. People die.

But the scariest thing isn't non-Euclidean geometry, is it? It's other people.

Bring the team back together. It's time to save a world.

(I read Last Exit as a Netgalley ARC.)
ursula: bear eating salmon (Default)
2021-01-04 07:44 pm
Entry tags:

January journal: forthcoming books

[personal profile] blackswanseer asked, "Is there a book you're particularly looking forward to coming out in 2021 and if so, what what has you excited about it?"

I've simultaneously been doing a lot of reviewing and a lot of comfort reading, which means I've already read some of the 2021 books I'm excited about (Desolation Called Peace and Galactic Hellcats, for example), while I'm behind on other series where I'd usually jump on the latest release (how did two more Foreigner books come out when I wasn't looking?). I'm excited about voting in the Hugos this year. I'm not a completist about my ballot, but last time around I definitely found stuff (especially in the novella and series categories) that I wouldn't otherwise have known about. 2021 Hugo voting means 2020 releases, though!

One book I'm definitely looking forward to is Aliette de Bodard's novella Fireheart Tiger. I know it has women falling in love, and fantasy based on Vietnamese history. I hope it also has some literal tigers!

(If you'd like to suggest another topic, you can do so here!)